Condition Guide

Every item we sell gets a 1 to 5 star rating and a set of condition pills. The stars are calculated from the condition answers, never typed in by hand. This page explains exactly what each rating and pill means so there are no surprises at pickup.

1. The Star Scale

Stars are color-coded so you can scan condition at a glance: green for 4-5★, yellow for 2-3★, and red for 1★. Tap the stars on any item card to see this explanation.

TOP GRADE

New and flawless. Works, no damage, nothing missing. The box may be opened or damaged; any box issue is shown as a pill.

VERY GOOD

Close to perfect: one small issue, or a used item in great shape. The pills say exactly what it is.

GOOD

A couple of issues, or one bigger one such as major damage or not working. Check the pills, notes and photos.

FAIR

Several issues. Expect repairs, cleaning or missing pieces. Good value if you can fix it up.

FOR PARTS

Doesn't work and has major damage or missing parts. Best for parts or repair.

2. New vs. Used

New

up to 5★

Brand new and unused. A 5-star rating is only ever given to new items with no issues. The box doesn't change the stars: if it's opened, damaged or missing, you'll see a pill such as Box Damage or No Box.

Used

up to 4★

Previously used or returned. Used items top out at 4 stars, even in great shape, so 5 stars always means new and flawless.

3. How We Calculate the Rating

Our listers answer the same short set of questions for every item: does it work, is it damaged, is anything missing, what's the box like, does it need assembly, and is it clean. The rating is calculated from those answers. Issues add up: every issue lowers the rating, so an item with two issues rates lower than an item with one.

  • No issues: 5★ (new) or 4★ (used)
  • One small issue (untested, minor damage, unknown parts…): 4★
  • Two small issues, or one bigger one (major damage, not working): 3★
  • Several issues: 2★
  • Not working, major damage and missing parts: 1★

Example

A new bookshelf in an opened box with hundreds of pieces that weren't individually checked shows Damage Unknown and Unknown if Missing Parts. Two small issues, so it rates 3★. The same bookshelf still sealed in its box rates 5★.

4. What Each Condition Pill Means

Item cards show only the pills worth noticing (yellow and red). The item page shows every answer, green ones included. Green is good, yellow is unknown or minor, and red is a known problem, which always comes with a note explaining it when something is missing, damaged or not working.

Functional Status

  • WorksTested and working· No effect on the stars
  • UntestedUntested - functional status unknown· Small issue (about 1 star)
  • Not WorkingNot working - see notes· Bigger issue (about 2 stars)

Damage

  • No DamageNo damage· No effect on the stars
  • Minor DamageMinor cosmetic damage· Small issue (about 1 star)
  • Major DamageMajor damage - see notes· Bigger issue (about 2 stars)
  • Damage UnknownNot inspected for damage· Small issue (about 1 star)

Missing Parts

  • CompleteComplete with all parts· No effect on the stars
  • Missing PartsMissing parts - see notes· Small issue (about 1 star)
  • Unknown if Missing PartsUnknown if missing parts· Small issue (about 1 star)
  • Partial SetPartial set - see notes· Small issue (about 1 star)

Box / Packaging

  • Box SealedIn original sealed box· No effect on the stars
  • Box OpenedOriginal box, opened· No effect on the stars
  • Box DamageOriginal box is damaged· No effect on the stars
  • No BoxNo original box· No effect on the stars

Assembly

  • No AssemblyReady to use· No effect on the stars
  • Assembly RequiredAssembly required· No effect on the stars

Cleanliness

  • CleanClean· No effect on the stars
  • DustyDusty - light cleaning needed· No effect on the stars
  • Dirty / StainedDirty or stained - needs cleaning· Small issue (about 1 star)
  • OdorHas an odor· Small issue (about 1 star)

5. "Sale Is Final" Items

Some listings are marked "SALE IS FINAL" — typically items with disclosed defects, missing parts, or damaged packaging. These items carry no warranty and cannot be returned under any circumstances.

The "Sale Is Final" designation is always shown clearly on the listing before you bid. By bidding on a "Sale Is Final" item, you waive any warranty rights for that item. See our Terms & Conditions for the full policy.

6. Photos Are Part of the Description

Every listing includes photos that show the actual item, not stock images. These photos are part of the condition disclosure — they may show cosmetic details (light scratches, packaging condition, etc.) that aren't spelled out in the written descriptors.

Before bidding, please review all photos carefully. It is your responsibility to inspect the photos and understand the item's condition. If anything isn't clear from the photos and descriptors, reach out before you bid.

7. Have Questions?

We're happy to clarify anything about an item's condition before you bid.